Current:Home > BackWhat would Lisa Simpson do? NYU student protesters asked to ponder ethical issues-InfoLens
What would Lisa Simpson do? NYU student protesters asked to ponder ethical issues
View Date:2024-12-23 15:09:38
NEW YORK (AP) — Would Lisa Simpson set up a tent at New York University to protest the war in Gaza? How would Principal Skinner respond if she did?
Hard to say, but some NYU students facing discipline for their actions during this spring’s pro-Palestinian protests have been assigned a 49-page workbook that includes a “Simpsons”-based module on ethical decision-making. Some have been asked to write an apologetic “reflection paper” and submit it “in 12-point Times New Roman or similar font.”
Like colleges across the U.S., NYU was the scene of protests over Israel’s response to the Oct. 7 Hamas attack during the last weeks of the spring semester.
More than 100 NYU students were arrested when police cleared an encampment at the university’s Manhattan campus on April 22, and about a dozen more were arrested at a smaller encampment on May 3.
NYU’s school year has ended, but the university is requiring some student protesters to go through a disciplinary process that includes answering questions like “What are your values? Did the decision you made align with your personal values?” in a double-spaced reflection paper.
Others must complete a 49-page “Ethos Integrity Series” that asks students to rank their values from 1 to 42 and complete assignments like “write about how your values affect your daily life and the decisions you make.”
One section is based on an episode of “The Simpsons” in which Lisa uncharacteristically cheats on a test and is wracked by guilt. Principal Skinner, meanwhile, wants to keep the cheating under wraps so the school can get a grant. Questions in the ethics workbook include “What, if anything, could Lisa have done or thought about to make better decisions?” and “What are the potential and actual consequences of Principal Skinner’s decisions?”
An NYU group called Faculty & Staff for Justice in Palestine criticized the assignments in a news release.
Sara Pursley, an associate professor of Middle Eastern and Islamic Studies, noted that students completing the reflection paper are told they must not try to justify their actions or “challenge a conduct regulation.”
“Since they can’t write anything justifying their action, students seem to be banned from writing about personal values that might be relevant here, such as a belief in freedom of expression, the responsibility to oppose genocide, or the duty of nonviolent civil disobedience under certain circumstances,” Pursley said. “This seems rather ironic in an essay on integrity.”
NYU spokesperson John Beckman said the disciplinary process is meant to be educational.
“The point of these essays is to reflect upon how a student’s way of expressing their values might be having an impact on other members of the NYU community,” Beckman said. “We think that’s a worthwhile goal.”
He added, “Which is not to say that the specific assignments couldn’t be improved.”
Faculty members and staff from NYU’s Office of Student Conduct will meet in the fall, Beckman said, to consider “what might be done to improve the quality of the prompts for the reflection papers as well as the other educational assignments.”
veryGood! (233)
Related
- Fantasy football Week 11: Trade value chart and rest of season rankings
- Few Republicans have confidence in elections. It’s a long road for one group trying to change that
- That Mixed Metal Jewelry Trend? Here’s How To Make It Your Own
- Illinois man fatally stabbed 6-year-old in hate crime motivated by Israeli-Hamas war, authorities say
- Colorado police shot, kill mountain lion after animal roamed on school's campus
- Pharmacy chain Rite Aid files for bankruptcy amid declining sales and opioid lawsuits
- The war between Israel and Hamas is testing the Republican Party’s isolationist shift
- Buffalo Bills hang on -- barely -- in a 14-9 win over the New York Giants
- Colorado police shot, kill mountain lion after animal roamed on school's campus
- What is curcumin? Not what you might think.
Ranking
- Tropical Storm Sara threatens to bring flash floods and mudslides to Central America
- AP PHOTOS: Israel-Hamas war’s 9th day leaves survivors bloody and grief stricken
- Miles Morales and Peter Parker pack an emotional punch in 'Marvel's Spider-Man 2'
- Migrant boat sinking off Greek island leaves 3 dead, 2 missing, 8 rescued
- The Daily Money: Inflation is still a thing
- The Israeli public finds itself in grief and shock, but many pledge allegiance to war effort
- 5 Things podcast: Blinken says Arab leaders don't want spillover from Israel-Hamas war
- Noted Iranian film director and his wife found stabbed to death in their home, state media report
Recommendation
-
Taking stock of bonds: Does the 60/40 rule still have a role in retirement savings?
-
What is direct indexing? How you can use it to avoid taxes like the super-rich
-
Pete Davidson talks on 'SNL' about Israel-Hamas war and losing his dad on 9/11
-
Israeli couple who were killed protecting their twin babies from Hamas gunmen were heroes, family says
-
Question of a lifetime: Families prepare to confront 9/11 masterminds
-
Semitruck driver killed when Colorado train derails, spilling train cars and coal onto a highway
-
DeSantis says US shouldn’t take in Palestinian refugees from Gaza because they’re ‘all antisemitic’
-
Pregnant Jana Kramer Hospitalized During Babymoon With Bacterial Infection in Her Kidneys